Countdown to April 29 to PERMANENTLY close M. R. Reiter. Ask the board to see the 6 point plan.

Friday, January 9, 2009

School board declares 'emergency' in Morrisville

From buckslocalnews.com

School board declares 'emergency' in Morrisville
By Petra Chesner Schlatter; Staff Editor Posted on Wed, Jan 7, 2009

MORRISVILLE -- In an 8-0 vote, the Morrisville School Board passed a resolution Jan. 5 declaring an emergency and authorizing certain purchases in the wake of the Dec. 13 furnace explosion at M.R. Reiter Elementary School.

Those purchases are contingent on whether or not the insurance company will pay for eight modulars.

A special hearing is scheduled for Jan. 29 about the possible closure of M.R. Reiter forever. The board majority, led by President Bill Hellman, is in favor of closing the school, despite opposition from parents. M.R. Reiter has been closed since the blast.

Paul DeAngelo, the school district's new business manager, told a full house at the special meeting that a report was scheduled to be released at press time about the composition of the soot, which was caused by the explosion.

After the meeting, DeAngelo said the report would tell whether carcinogens were found in the soot. He confirmed that asbestos was confined to the chimney of the furnace.

DeAngelo gave a detailed presentation about how much it would cost to lease eight modulars, which would be installed at Grandview Elementary School.

The board approved the leasing of eight modular classrooms with restrooms from Mobilease Modular Space, Inc. of Thoro-fare, N.J. The total cost over two years would be $433,472 plus the cost for delivery costs to dismantle and return the modulars.

The cost would be $5,760 per month for 24 months plus $6,400 delivery, $98,932 for set-up and $189,900 for utilities.

With the vote approving the modulars, the configuration of which grades will go where will change. Some parents attending the special meeting were concerned that fifth-graders would attend classes at the Morrisville Middle/Senior High School.

Dr. Elizabeth Yonson, superintendent, assured the audience that if M.R. Reiter were to be closed, fifth graders would be segregated from the sixth-graders at the middle/senior high school. But she stressed that a configuration plan is not yet in place because the school board would have to approve one.

Yonson also noted that the Pre-Kindergarten classes, which have been held at the YMCA, could go to the middle/high school. She said this is done in other school districts and that high school students often work with that population.

First-and second-grades would attend class in the modulars. Kindergarten classes would be held in Grandview Elementary. Third-and fourth-grades would remain at the main building at Grandview.

Yonson described the modulars as "very nice" and "great." She noted there would be bathrooms in the classrooms and covered walkways for children. The modulars would be air-conditioned. She said without air conditioning, summer was "unbearable on the second floor of M.R. Reiter."

"There will be new carpeting," Yonson said. "They look absolutely brand new. When you walk in, you would not know you were in a modular."

One parent was concerned about the noise that would be created when the modulars were installed. Yonson said there would be less noise than in the older modulars now at M.R. Reiter.

"We need to do something immediately so our children and teachers have a quality education," Yonson said.

Opening the public comment section was former School Board Member Johanny Manning, who had advocated building the controversial $30-million consolidated school complex. That plan called for housing all grades in one facility.

Manning served on the school board before the new majority took control of the school board after the November 2007 elections. The new majority was part of a slate to stop plans for the school complex. The new board stopped the school from being built.

Saying the current problems with M.R. Reiter were inevitable, Manning asserted that the problem would have occurred regardless of whom was serving on the school board.

"I have to say, 'We told you so,'" Manning said. "We knew that the furnaces were long past their expectancy. I don't want to hear it's a total surprise. It's been happening for years. I say, shame on you!"

Manning said the school year has "truly been interrupted."

She criticized the school board for "spending a half-million dollars not knowing what we will do in a month. If the building is not reopened, how do we change the configuration?"

Yonson said insurance would pay for the modulars, it is not coming from district funds.

Jon Perry, a Morrisville Borough resident, told the audience to continue attending school board meetings. "You really have to keep your eye on this board," he said. Perry added that people should "try to get [board members] to do the right thing."

Perry said the current board majority "forges ahead" with "inadequate information."

School Board Member Bill Farrell said, "I come here month in and month out. It's a circus. Forget what's happened in the past." He said M.R. Reiter was a "time bomb."

One resident said that "all three schools are time bombs."

One idea that was raised was using Manor Elementary School to ease crowding at Grandview because of M.R. Reiter students being placed at Grandview.

However, Mike Fitzpatrick, board solicitor, said the district and the Head Start program have a lease/purchase agreement for 20 years. He said using Manor, which is owned by the school district, would probably not be an option.

Parents asked when teachers would be able to get the rest of their teaching materials. One parent alleged that the teachers were just "babysitting" the children. But, Yonson and Laurie Ruffing, acting elementary principal, said that was not true. Teachers were able to go into M.R. Reiter after the blast to get some of what they needed.

The teachers, Ruffing said, will get additional materials before the clean-up effort at M.R. Reiter is complete.

During the meeting, other parents expressed their concerns about the morning drop-off and afternoon pick-up of students. They said that more crossing guards are needed at the high school for the students' safety.

6 comments:

Jon said...

Jab jab jab jab jab, inflammatory off-base remark, can't we all just get along and work together? Jab jab jab jab jab, inflammatory off-base remark, can't we all just get along and work together? Jab jab jab jab jab, can't we all just get along and work together?

I've learned that there are some people you just can't get along with, and who simply don't play well with others. Several of them sit on the school board and on boro council. Some in our citizenry write letters to the editor like the one below from today's BCCT.

Can we all just get along and work together? Probably not. But we can put more open-minded people into elected positions. The May 19th primary election is next chance to do it.


Yet another excuse to sow division and cast blame

It would be better to live in a place without a lot of services that become the convenient hiding places to provide justification for raising taxes. Yardley, repeatedly devastated by flooding, and without the millions of dollars Morrisville receives from hosting bridges and processing toxic landfill runoff, has managed not to raise taxes for the past few years and, in fact, has lower taxes than Morrisville. Other surrounding communities are providing rebates while Morrisville raises taxes.

While waiting to vote on Election Day, a man from the local Democratic club approached people in line and advised them to vote for increased funding for the rescue squad, claiming it would be necessary to offset the payments the insurance company refused to honor. Do other communities share this experience and why should we be expected to subsidize insurance company obligations? Doesn't this set a risky precedent?

And while surrounding communities seek to preserve diminishing open space to enhance the quality of life for their communities, Morrisville council members apparently scoff at the notion. One is left to wonder where their priorities are and who they serve.

We had to replace the heating system soon after we moved in our house, it blew soot everywhere. Yet when the heater goes on the blitz in a Morrisville school, rather than simply addressing the problem, it becomes yet another excuse to sow division and cast blame, with columnist Kate Fratti ascending her soapbox to launch a one-sided attack against the voters' mandate.

She never questions or holds Pennsbury accountable for not including the handful of Morrisville students excluded from the district they sit in the middle of. And if the schools are so atrocious in every respect, why would any parent want to move to Morrisville in the first place?

Such disrespectful public displays of animosity and conflict can't be positive role models for children; and if the children really matter, shouldn't petitioning to be included in a highly credited district be worthwhile? Aren't your precious babies worth it?

Why not work together to pursue a low-cost solution instead of turning to the increasingly strapped Morrisville taxpayer to foot the bill.

Raphaelle del Vecchio
Morrisville

Ken said...

"...would be $433,472 plus the cost for delivery costs to dismantle and return the modulars."

Those "delivery costs" to return the modules will never be paid ... if the 'temporary' modules become 'permanent' like the ones at MRR. Another 'Hellmann' cost saving measure?

"One idea that was raised was using Manor Elementary School..."

Did I not predict that this would be echoed back on January 5th ?

And I haven't heard a peep from the MEA about all of this. Aren't they affraid abunch of teachers will be laid off when the school closes permanently?

Peter said...

I thought this response on Phillyburbs.com to del Vecchio's letter was interesting:

"As a former resident of Morrisville and now of Lower Makefield, the problems they face now have been there since the early 80s. The problem isn't republican or democrat. The problem is their school system. Why pay extraordinary taxes for a sub-par education in Morrisville, when you can move less than a mile down the road and pay less taxes for an above par education? Pennsbury knows this, and for the life of me I will never understand why the merger talked about for the last 30 years hasn't happened yet. Will it take the total collapse of the Morrisville School District for Pennsbury to incorporate it? I have a feeling it will. It's a shame really, because what are we really talking about here other than a few invisible lines on a map and the education of children. That or Pennsbury has some kind of grudge against Morrisville."

Jon said...

I agree with the first 4 sentences, but I have some trouble with the rest.

Why hasn't a merger talked with Pennsbury happened? Why on earth would Pennsbury merge with Morrisville? What's in it for them? You can't expect a school district to feel sorry for another school district and absorb it out of pure altruism. I don't think Pennsbury has a grudge against Morrisville. I just don't think there's anything, or enough, in it for them.

I believe that, after the last 13 months under the current Morrisville board majority, there's less in it for Pennsbury than there ever has been. Despite improved Morrisville test scores, which is in no way attributable to this board, we have a board majority that has failed to address the conditions of its school buildings and had one school building experience a furnace explosion and become unusable on its watch. Elementary school kids are currently jammed into the Middle-High School and the other elementary school, with pre-K kids at the YMCA. At best, these kids will be put into trailers for many months, if not longer.

Bond monies set aside to build a new K-12 campus, which could have been a long-term solution to address building conditions, were largely given back, and it cost a lot of money ($2.5 million) to do it. Not enough money remains to properly renovate the school buildings. Special education and other educational programs were underbudgeted.

We have an arrogant, hostile school board majority whose president tells people not to invest in Morrisville, despite its desperate need to increase business (non-residential) tax ratables. A board majority that has received gobs of, unfortunately, well-deserved bad press that has tarnished Morrisville's already dubious reputation in the region. Do you think people in Pennsbury don't read the papers? It's heinous attitude towards concerned parents has probaly succeeded in driving young families out of town, and prevented others from moving here.

I think there's a mentality that believes the state, or some other savior, will swoop in and force a merger if things get bad enough. I don't know, maybe this board is trying to speed that process along. I don't buy into this "we have to destroy the village to save it" mentality. I think it's bunk, a dream, the kind of stuff powerless people who don't have any connection to power say, probably out of false hope.

Peter said...

"Not enough money remains to properly renovate the school buildings."

This is very much true, as (yet another) Vitetta's study has shown. And, sadly, the explosion at Reiter has cost us more than a half million dollars of our savings. Now, the insurance may cover it but to my knowledge this has not yet been determined and it just might not.

Save The School said...

Jon said in an earlier comment that "Bond monies set aside to build a new K-12 campus, which could have been a long-term solution to address building conditions, were largely given back, and it cost a lot of money ($2.5 million) to do it."

I take minor issue with this statement. We did not "give back" the money. We sold it back. That was our 30 pieces of silver.

If I were the Pennsbury administration, I would be very concerned about taking on the Morrisville responsibilities. Our students would be OK. Our buildings would bankrupt them.

Paradoxically, the new K-12 building would have ENHANCED the chances for a Pennsbury merger. Imagine bringing that as our dowry to bestow upon Pennsbury rather than two 50 year old buildings and one potentially contaminated 80 year old building.