Countdown to April 29 to PERMANENTLY close M. R. Reiter. Ask the board to see the 6 point plan.

Wednesday, December 17, 2008

Borough Council Sez: Open Your Wallets Wider, Please

From the BCCT.

Kudos to Hizzoner. I'm not all that happy that the current condition of our police department is posted for public consumption. However, Tom Wisnosky's generosity is a genuine piece of good news coming from a rather grim week of news featuring the 'Ville.


Council approves budget with $70 tax hike
The mayor is donating his 2009 salary for new guns for police officers.
By DANNY ADLER
STAFF WRITER

Morrisville residents will pay about $70 more next year in municipal property taxes, according to a final budget approved unanimously this week by the council.

On Monday it approved a $5.77 million spending plan — up about $500,000 from this year’s budget — with increased expenses for public works, emergency services and rising sanitation charges.

The millage will increase 3.5 mills to 39.43 mills next year and a homeowner with a property assessed at the borough average of $20,000 will pay about $788 in borough taxes, about $70 more than this year.

One mill, or about $60,000, of the tax hike is allocated for public works trucks and equipment. Another mill will go to the Morrisville Fire Co. for new fire equipment. One and a half mills of the increase, roughly $90,000, are set for the Morrisville Ambulance Squad after being approved by voter referendum.

The residential sanitation charges are set at $357, a $15 increase. The commercial charge will increase $26 to $606. The sanitation increases make up for rising costs by the borough’s trash hauler, Allied Waste Services.

The largest expense for the borough continues to be its police department, accounting for $1.53 million of borough spending.

With a $60,000 increase for the police department budget over this year’s, the borough will fork out money for higher department salaries, as well as office and equipment improvements.

Mayor Thomas Wisnosky said Monday night that he will donate his $2,900 salary next year to the police department so it can purchase new guns for its officers.

Wisnosky said the department uses weapons that are “20-some years old.” “That’s way too old,” the mayor said.

So What's Grandview's Condition?

Let's take a look at the the 2005 buildings report to see how things looked almost four years ago at Grandview, where our kindergarteners are now temporarily housed. Keep in mind, every single person on the current board has seen this report. Angry Al Radosti, Brenda Worob, and Gloria Heater were members of the previous board who refused to believe this report was accurate and helped to bring conditions to where we are today.

2.0 Grandview Elementary
Executive Summary
Original 1954 Building: With the exception of the recently replaced clock system, the HVAC, P&D, FP, and EPT&D must be replaced.

1968 Addition: With the exception of the electrical service, wiring, main sanitary, fire alarm,
public address, security and clock systems, HVAC, P&D, FP, and EPT&D.

2.1 Heating, Ventilating and Air Conditioning Systems and Equipment
2.1.1 Air Handling Units
General:
• Two air handling units, with electric cooling and hot water heating, were installed in 1968. The air handling units, each dedicated to one large classroom in the 1968 Addition, have been abandoned in-place.
• An oil-fired air handling unit, located in the first floor mechanical room, serves offices and classroom in the original 1956 Building. Refer to Photograph B1 in Appendix “B”.
• Air is distributed through a combination of galvanized steel ductwork and underground asbestos cement pipe. The asbestos cement pipe is limited to the original 1956 Building.
Refer to Photograph B2 in Appendix “B”.
Age/Condition:
• The air handling units and ductwork are approximately forty years old and have far exceeded their useful service lives.
Code Issues:
• Not applicable.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The air handling units and ductwork systems are not acceptable for reuse or continued use, and must be removed.

2.1.2 Boilers
General:
• Two oil-fired boilers, which generate space heating hot water for classroom and corridor
heating, serve the HVAC equipment in the 1968 Addition. Refer to Photograph B4 in
Appendix “B”.
• Two base-mounted pumps circulate heating water throughout the 1968 Addition. Refer to Photograph B5 in Appendix “B”.
Age/Condition:
• The boilers are approximately thirty-seven years old and have far exceeded their useful service lives;
• The base-mounted pumps appear to be approximately five years old and can be expected to last another ten to fifteen years. The space heating hot water system may not be thebest system choice to serve an upgraded facility with modern space program.
Code Issues:
• There are no apparent code issues related to the base-mounted pumps.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The boilers are not suitable for reuse and must be replaced.
• The pumps are not suited for the new HVAC systems and must be replaced.

2.1.3 Cooling System
General:
• Classrooms in the 1968 Addition are equipped with through-wall units with direct expansion cooling coils, hot water heating coils and ventilation air provisions. Refer to
Photograph B6 in Appendix “B”.
• Supplemental cooling systems consist of several ductless split systems in various offices and classrooms. Refer to Photograph B7 in Appendix “B”.
• Window air conditions are not addressed within this report.
Age/Condition:
• The through-wall air conditioning units are over thirty years old and beyond their useful service lives.
• Ductless split system units do not provide code required ventilation air and are not suitable for a schoolhouse occupancy.
Code Issues:
• Not applicable.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The through-wall air conditioning units and ductless split systems are not suitable for reuse and must be replaced.

2.1.4 Underground Oil Tanks
General:
• A 10,000 gallon underground oil tank, located on the west side of the 1968 mechanical room, serves the two hot water boilers. Refer to Photograph B8 in Appendix “B”.
• An oil pump set, located in the first floor mechanical room, supplies oil from the underground tank to the boilers. Refer to Photograph B9 in Appendix “B”.
• A 6,000 gallon underground oil tank, located on the south side of the 1956 mechanical room, serves the oil-fired air handling unit.
Age/Condition:
• The oil tanks and pumps are over forty years old and have far exceeded their useful service lives.
Code Issues:
• Any repair work resulting from leaks will subject the overall system to compliance with stringent, expensive Federal Environmental Requirements. Prudent evaluation of existing tank/piping system integrity and lead free performance is recommended. Suitability for General Reuse:
• The oil tank and oil pumps are not suitable for reuse or continued use, and must be replaced.

2.1.5 Automatic Temperature Control System
General:
• Automatic temperature control system is pneumatic and is served by an air compressor located in the 1968 Boiler Room. Refer to Photograph B10 in Appendix “B”.
Age/Condition:
• The control system appears to be over twenty years old and has far exceeded its useful service life.
Code Issues:
• Not applicable.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The control system is not suitable for reuse, continued use, and must be replaced.

2.1.6 Exhaust System
General:
• General and toilet room exhaust is provided by roof mounted fans.
Age/Condition:
• The exhaust fans are over thirty years old and have far exceeded their useful service lives.
Code Issues:
• Not applicable.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The exhaust systems are not suitable for reuse and must be removed.

2.2 Plumbing Systems and Equipment
2.2.1 Plumbing Fixtures
General:
• Plumbing fixtures consist of water closets, urinals, lavatories, water coolers and hand sinks located throughout the school. Refer to Photographs B11 and B12 in Appendix “B”.
Age/Condition:
• The majority of the plumbing fixtures appear to be at least thirty years old, have far exceeded their useful service lives, are in part faulty, and not capable of repair.
Code Issues:
• Systems are unable to meet Pennsylvania State System Performance Requirements.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• A majority of the plumbing fixtures are not suitable for continued use, much less reuse in an upgraded schoolhouse facility, and must be replaced.

2.2.2 Sanitary and Vent Piping
General:
• The piping is concealed in the construction and was not directly observed. For the purposes of this report, it is assumed the piping is cast-iron and of original construction.
• There are not reported problems with the main building sewer.
Age/Condition:
• Sanitary and vent piping system is over forty years old and has far exceeded its useful service lives.
Code Issues:
• Not applicable.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The sanitary and vent piping is not suitable for reuse in an upgraded facility with modern space program, and must be replaced.
• Reuse of the existing main building sewer under a modernized program of space should be reviewed with the Municipal Sewer Authority.

2.2.3 Domestic Water Piping
General:
• The visible piping is copper and the majority appears to be of original construction.
• A two-inch Municipal water service supplies the property via an entry at the mechanical
room on the south side of the building. There are no reported problems with the service
entrance.
Age/Condition:
• The majority of the domestic water piping is reported to be over forty years old and has exceeded its useful service life.
• The Municipal Water Service Entrance Piping System appears to be at least twenty years old, and is unreliable at best.
Code Issues:
• Not applicable.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The domestic water piping is not suitable for reuse in an updated, modernized program of space use, and must be replaced.
• The Municipal Water Company should be consulted to determine suitability of overall property water service entrance for expansion of useful capacity.

2.2.4 Domestic Water Heaters
General:
• One small electric water heater, located in the 1956 mechanical room, provides domestic
hot water to the plumbing fixtures in the original building. Refer to Photograph B13 in
Appendix “B”.
• A propane-fired water heater, located in the Boiler Room, serves plumbing fixtures in the 1968 Addition. Refer to Photograph B14 in Appendix “B”.
Age/Condition:
• The electric water heater appears to be less than five years old and in good condition.
• The propane-fired water heater appears to be over twenty years old and beyond its useful service life. The system may be unsafe in view of the age of the existing system, and original safety devices now required of equipment manufacturers.
Code Issues:
• There are no apparent code issues related to the electric water heaters.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The electric water heaters are suitable for reuse. The need for additional capacity must be determined.
• The propane-fired water heater is not suitable for reuse and must be replaced.

2.3 Fire Protection Systems and Equipment
2.3.1 Automatic Fire Suppression. If substantial renovation is planned, a trade off cost study will be required to compare fire isolation affected by general construction barriers to full building fire sprinklering at $4.00 per square foot.
General:
• There are no automatic fire suppression systems in the building. If substantial renovation is planned, a trade off cost study will be required to compare fire isolation affected by general construction barriers to full building fire sprinklering at $4.00 per square foot.

2.4 Electrical Systems and Equipment
2.4.1 Electric Service
General:
• An underground 4160 VAC electrical service runs from a PECO utility pole on Grandview Avenue to a 150 KVA unit substation with 120/208 VAC secondary located off the new boiler room. The electric service is metered “PD” rate. Refer to Photograph B15 in Appendix “B”.
Age/Condition:
• Electrical service equipment is approximately thirty-five years old, and is in fair condition.
Code Issues:
• There are no apparent code issues related to the electric service.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The electrical service equipment is suitable for reuse, assuming that electrical load resulting from an expanded program of space use, does not exceed existing capacity.

2.4.2 Branch Circuit Panelboards
General:
• Branch circuit panels throughout the building supply lighting and general power circuits.
The majority of the panels are circuit breaker type except for the original fuse equipped
main distribution panel.
Age/Condition:
• Branch circuit panelboards are approximately thirty-five years old, are in poor condition, and have far exceeded their useful life. Spare breakers are not available.
Code Issues:
• Panels in the main electric room have insufficient clearance, thereby failing to meet the National Electrical Code.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• Panelboards are not suitable for reuse, or continued use.

2.4.3 Interior Lighting Fixtures
General:
• Each classroom has three rows of stem mounted, two lamp T-12, fluorescent direct/indirect light fixtures. Refer to Photograph B16 in Appendix “B” for typical classroom light fixtures. Corridor lighting is generally 2 x 4 lay-in with prismatic lens and T-12 lamps. Office lighting is 2 x 4 stem mounted with wrap around lens and T-12 lamps.
Age/Condition:
• Fluorescent light fixtures are thirty-five years old, are in poor conditions, are not energy efficient and contain “PCB” (HAZMAT) ballasts.
Code Issues:
• Not applicable.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• Light fixtures are not suitable for reuse, or continued use.

2.4.4 Emergency Lighting
General:
• Battery powered emergency light units are used in the corridors and lobby in the original building. The newer building has a 15 Kw emergency generator with automatic transfer switch, plug fuse panel, and incandescent lights.
Age/Condition:
• Emergency lighting units are in fair condition. The 15Kw emergency generator is about
forty years old, and parts are unavailable.
Code Issues:
• The emergency-only circuits are no longer acceptable under applicable life safety code. Suitability for General Reuse:
• The entire emergency lighting system and generator are not suitable for reuse, or continued use.

2.4.5 Exterior Lighting Fixtures
General:
• External lighting fixtures are generally wall mounted incandescent floodlights and lights
over exit doors.
Age/Condition:
• Exterior light fixtures are in poor condition and are not energy efficient.
Code Issues:
• Not applicable.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• Exterior lights are not suitable for reuse.

2.4.6 Fire Alarm and Fire Detection System
General:
• The fire alarm system is a non-coded addressable system with pull stations and
notification devices.
• Audio/visual alarm units are located in corridors but do not serve toilet rooms or
classrooms.
• Fire alarm control equipment is manufactured by Silent Night Company, and replacement
parts are available. All alarms report to a central station. Refer to Photograph B17 in
Appendix “B”. The Owner reports no problems with false alarms.
• None of the areas were equipped with heat or smoke detectors.
Age/Condition:
• Fire alarm and detection system equipment is approximately two years old and is in good
condition.
Code Issues:
• Classrooms and toilet rooms do not have audio/visual alarm units, which does not comply in accordance with the Americans With Disabilities Act. Smoke detectors must be added to comply with latest codes.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• Fire alarm system equipment is suitable for reuse. The system must be expanded for
addition of code required smoke detectors and audio/visual alarm units.

2.4.7 Public Address System
General:
• The Public Address (PA) and communication equipment was manufactured by Bogen
Company, and includes: control panel in the administration office; speakers in all
classrooms, corridors and offices; and handsets that provide intercommunication between classrooms and the main office.
Age/Condition:
• The PA system is in good condition and is eight years old.
Code Issues:
• There are no apparent code issues related to the PA system.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• PA system equipment is suitable for reuse.

2.4.8 Computer Data Network System
General:
• There are individual computers in the classrooms. A centralized network system does not exist.

2.4.9 Clock and Change of Class Program System
General:
• The original master clock has been replaced with a Lathom Corporation clock system. Replacement parts are available for this system. The clock control panel is located in the administration office and clocks are located in all classrooms. Refer to Photograph B18
in Appendix “B”.
Age/Condition:
• The master clock is approximately three years old and is in good condition.
Code Issues:
• There are no apparent code issues related to the clock system.
Suitability for General Reuse:
• The overall system is suitable for reuse.

2.4.10 Security and Intrusion Detection System
General:
• Classrooms and entry corridor are protected with motion detectors with an audio alarm output device. Ultraguard manufactured the equipment, replacement parts are available for this system.
Age/Condition:
• The intrusion detection system equipment is approximately three years old and is in good condition.
Code Issues:
• There are no apparent code issues related to the security system
Suitability for General Reuse:
• Intrusion detection system is suitable for reuse and expansion.

Fratti: One school down. Two to go.

Kate Fratti in the BCCT.

Come see the Emperor and the Board of Chosen Accomplices in concert TONIGHT, 7:30 P.M. in the LGI.

Please make them move the meeting to the auditorium. Bring a friend. Bring a neighbor. Bring your kids. Show the kids what democracy is all about and show the board members that the students of Morrisville are worth fighting for.


Morrisville going down?

If you think Morrisville school board members are wringing their hands after learning the borough will block the reopening of M.R. Reiter Elementary School until engineers deem it “safe,” you’ve been had.

While grade-schoolers are displaced, staff is scrambling, the maintenance guy is explaining and parents are up in arms, the mood of the board leadership following the boiler room explosion at Reiter is celebratory. Dollar signs everywhere. The explosion was a Christmas gift.

In an e-mail written to the rest of the board fewer than 24 hours after the boiler blew, board President Bill Hellmann indicated a shuttered M.R. Reiter is just what he’d hoped for. The emphasis is all his.

“If we close both elementary schools and put everybody in the high school, we will save a FORTUNE in operating costs. EVERY YEAR. The pro new-schoolers wanted a K-12 school. Well here it is. The other people who might not want a K-12 are a minority and when they see their reduced tax bill on July 1 of each year, they just may change their minds in these new tough economic times. We will save ANOTHER fortune by not repairing either of those two buildings. We will solve the M.R. Reiter problem. CLOSE THIS RAT TRAP NOW.”

Hellmann’s e-mail makes it clear why in June he eliminated Reiter from a list of buildings to be examined by engineers in preparation for eventual renovations that might have prevented the explosion. And, it’s clear, now, why the board’s been dragging its feet on fixes to Grandview Elementary School, too.

Rat traps.

Hellmann, Brenda Worob, Marlys Mihok, Al Radosti, Bill Farrell and Gloria Heater were voted into office by an electorate that desperately wanted to stop construction of a new K-12 building it could not afford. The winning slate promised voters they’d renovate existing buildings instead.

They lied. Some of them have said privately they’d like to rid the borough of the entire school system.

One school down. Two to go.

So what until then?

It’s rumored school board directors have spoken with council members about using county open space preservation funds to purchase the Reiter property and that county Commissioner Jim Cawley has offered to assist them with such a plan.

Cawley insists he has not had any such conversation with anyone from Morrisville — though the county’s always willing to help when it can, he added.

Which, I suppose, suggests the open space suggestion isn’t so farfetched. How else to unload rat trap real estate? Morrisville will need to spend its open space allotment or lose it, and what other open space is there?

The stumbling block to eliminating the whole district immediately? A teachers contract that blocks lay-offs and furloughs for the next few years. The Reiter boiler explosion blew open a path to save at least some “FORTUNE” now by eliminating operating costs.

It will mean cramming gradeschoolers into space at the high school and eventually reconfiguring high school classrooms to create a grade-school wing.

Learning in the midst of all that commotion? You never hear this board use the word. It’s not their concern.

They came into power with an agenda to be rid of schools entirely. They should have said so up front. They might very well have been elected, anyway.

Either way, stating their intention was the honorable thing to do. This sneaky approach is disruptive, chaotic and bad for the borough’s reputation as a place to live and work. It could have been dangerous.

“If this school district does not wake up, this town is going down,” Hellmann e-mailed the rest of the board as he urged consensus.

His critics argue the descent already has begun. The cart’s being driven by sneaks and bean counters.

UPDATE December 18, from the BCCT.

CORRECTIONS & CLARIFICATIONS
Morrisville School Board member Brenda Worob was voted into office in 2005. Her term expires in 2009. Incorrect information appeared in Kate Fratti’s column Wednesday.
The Courier Times strives for accuracy. However, when we do make errors, we want to correct them as soon as possible in this space. To help us, please call 215-949-4161 (days) or 215-949-4211 (nights).

Moving students angers some parents

From the BCCT.

Moving students angers some parents
Reiter Elementary remains closed. Students are attending classes at three different sites, and that has parents concerned.
By MANASEE WAGH

M.R. Reiter Elementary School students have been uprooted from their classrooms.

And parents are angry.

A furnace explosion Saturday is keeping Reiter closed until at least Jan. 5. More than 250 students will have temporary classes in the middle/high school, the Morrisville YMCA and Grandview Elementary School. Nobody was hurt in the explosion, but the school remains closed while the borough and the district insurance company investigate the cause.

On Tuesday, district officials met with a large crowd of parents in the Morrisville Middle/High School gym to show them where their kids will learn for the next several days. Teachers took parents on tours of classrooms and spaces where their first- and second-graders will restart today. The young students will stay with teachers and aides at all times without mixing with higher grades, said administrators.

Families had many questions and complaints. They said they wished the school board, which has been in office a year, had fixed known facilities problems earlier.

“This is a nightmare,” said Tammi Bresen, the mother of a first-grader at Reiter. She didn’t like that three first-grade classes had to learn in makeshift classrooms in the library, with only a partial wall separating them.

“People aren’t happy, especially because the (furnace) was already having problems before,” said Jim Mahler, the father of a Reiter child. He said the board should fix the furnace immediately.

Oil odors began the afternoon of Dec. 10 in Reiter and then resumed Thursday morning, forcing students to leave while the district had a fuel pump replaced by an outside company. Later the furnace exploded, breaking a window in the boiler room.

One probable reason for the explosion is that the fuel valve to turn the fuel flow on and off got stuck in the open position, allowing fuel to continue pumping even after the burner shut off, said Tim Lastichen, the district’s director of facilities.

The district’s insurance company will likely pay for cleanup and repairs, said Elizabeth Yonson, district superintendent, Tuesday.

Built in the 1920’s, Reiter is older and in worse shape than Grandview, even without counting the boiler explosion, Lastichen said. Vitetta, the engineering and architectural firm the school board hired to analyze district schools, will probably report higher renovation costs for Reiter, he added.

William Hellmann, the school board president, said he expects the completed Vitetta report this week.

Some parents questioned whether Reiter would be closed permanently. Tonight, the board plans to discuss having a public hearing to close one of its two elementary schools. If the county buys the land as preserved open space, said Hellmann, the remaining two schools would benefit from the money. It could be used for renovation, he said.

However, Nancy Sherlock, president of the borough council, said Tuesday that she doesn’t think the borough would buy the land. Nor would the borough plan to prevent the district from reopening Reiter, as current rumors of an injunction suggest.

“An injunction means usurping power. We aren’t doing that,” she said, adding, “I don’t think the borough needs any more open space. I can’t speak for other council members.”

Hellmann said he would be amenable to a single school building for all students, “if we could work it out that way, but I’m not sure the town wants a kindergarten through 12thgrade school. We’d always have to have at least one elementary school,” he said.

“I am not averse to spending money on the school district as long as the money is spent efficiently. I don’t have specific examples of how right now,” continued Hellmann.

One thing sticks in Hellmann’s mind: three buildings for less than 900 children are too many, he said.

“To me it’s just common sense,” he said.

Trying to integrate hundreds of additional students into the high school would be a logistical nightmare, especially without constructing new building additions to make sure upper and lower grades don’t mix, administration officials said. Different hallways in the high school have dedicated spaces like computer labs, science labs and the woodshop. Right now, the cafeteria and library cater to upper grades only.

If a public hearing to sell a building takes place, the school board would have to wait 90 days before making the decision to sell it or not, according to school code.

Robin Tohm, the elementary schools’ PTO president, urged parents to attend tonight’s school board meeting and make their voices heard.

Yonson told parents at Tuesday’s open house that she would not send students back to Reiter unless air quality experts and cleanup crews say the school is safe.

“Everyone has been wonderful and pitching in to make things as easy as possible to manage for the next (several) days. I’m very grateful for the flexibility of the staff,” Yonson said. “I’m very hopeful we will be able to get kids back to Reiter. But it’s up to the board,” she added.