Countdown to April 29 to PERMANENTLY close M. R. Reiter. Ask the board to see the 6 point plan.

Saturday, January 26, 2008

Defeasement, Part II

So where do we go from here? The three schools are in pretty sad shape. M.R. Reiter, the worst of the three, is not salvageable without major renovation. I partially agree with Marlys Mihok that the site would make a great park. It would also make a great light business location too. Maybe doctor's offices or accounting offices, something like that. Why can't we make the location assume some of our tax burden and become productive? This is a debate for another time though.

Grandview is in bad shape too. This is the unspoken assumption that was there in the K-12 proposal from the previous board: All three schools are in bad shape. All of those parents who thought that the elementary schools were somehow "safe" from major upheaval once the evil K-12 building was defeated need to re-examine the situation. Renovation items from all three schools were, quite reasonably, postponed under the assumption that a new building was coming. Now they need to be addressed.

We're going to be renovating the Six Million Dollar Shell. Is that enough money to do the job? Aside from Emperor William Hellmann CPA, I'm not sure anyone else believes it is.

There are four boilers at MHS and all need replacement. Will they stay as fuel oil boilers, or convert over to gas? Where are energy prices heading? I assume that "down" is a safe incorrect answer.

The current windows assume cheap fuel prices. Will the new windows be the same size or smaller? Smaller means the walls need to be addressed as well, and the current AC units removed and patched over.

Electric? What's coming into the school, circa 1957, assumes open windows in warm weather (no AC units) and the occasional filmstrip projector being used. Today, there are multiple computers in each room (with each monitor, CPU, and printer needing an outlet), coffee makers, microwave ovens, electric pencil sharpeners, fans, televisions. I would safely assume that the electricity being used today is 10 times over what it used to be back in the Eisenhower Administration.

That's the tip of it. How many home repairs have you done only to find that the job is more that you expected? One items leads to another and soon, there's ten items to repair where there once was only one.

So this is where the engineers and architects come in. They need to survey what's there, what can be done, and the cost to do it. Has this been done yet? Where are the written reports, estimates, quotes, findings. etc? What plan is being used here, other than the plans of Emperor William Hellman CPA?

Incidentally, considering the William Hellman CPA designed and maintained borough finances are tanking too, tell me again why we're allowing him to work on the school budget. Someone? Anyone? The lack of a borough tax base is one of the reasons why this issue has arisen, and what did William Hellman CPA do to make things better or worse?

We also have to consider the capacity of the buildings. Will the physical MHS site accommodate a K-12 building? I don't have the floor plans and utilization figures available to me. My answer is *probably*, but I don't know. Reiter is a goner, so maybe renovate Grandview as well as a K-3 or 4 building, and bring the 5th grade over to MHS if there's not enough room. OK. Will six million refurbish TWO shells? Oops...maybe we need to keep $10 million? Well, since no one is doing the due diligence, who knows? We need to establish the costs involved in each of the options, along with the pluses and minuses. These are feasibility studies in the real world. Where is the MVSB's study? Nowhere, that's where.

There's a lot of emotion that goes with this whole question, and we've paid the price for it over the past few years. The seniors feel cheated out of their retirement money. The parents feel cheated out of a safe educational facility for their children. All of the homeowners feel cheated by the lack of a tax base to relieve the crippling taxes.

Let's sit back and take a deep breath and dispassionately examine this issue openly (sorry, Marlys, no executive sessions) with a somewhat open mind and in a general spirit of cooperation. The truth, and the eventual solution, lies somewhere in the middle, where it always was. We just need one of Kate Fratti's heroes to lead us to that point.

Who is going to step up?

Defeasment, Part I

Outside of the magical world of CPAs and other money mavens, the word defeasement is not used in casual conversation. I'm not sure it's used in conversation period. However, the good citizens of Morrisville have this word on their minds and tongues quite a bit lately. Do not forget the special board meeting on Wednesday, January 30, at 7:30 P.M. in the MHS LGI room. Please, please, click on that link and read the entire text. It will confuse many of us. Keep in mind that some of the board members are confused and uncertain as well. This is an important issue, maybe even more important than the farming issue.

The root of the word is in "defeat" and there are several dictionary entries and explanations I found for the word in Infoplease, the National Council of Health Facilities Finance Authority, Wikipedia, and a California public entity law firm.

The new school is dead and anyone who supported it must accept this reality.

So now we have money left over from the $30 million bond issue less the "two million dollars that were used for Lord knows what!" that the Stop the Schoolers fondly mention.

This money was borrowed for a period of years, for a purpose, at an interest rate, and it is obligated to be paid off. It's nothing more than a new car loan with lots more zeroes at the end, except that it's hard to repossess a building, and the taxpayers are footing the bill in the form of their taxes.

So, just like a mortgage or car loan, it can be repurposed and refinanced as needed providing the legal dotted Is and crossed Ts are all in place.

William Hellmann CPA maintains that the borrowing interest rate is too high. Yes, it is high. The more money you borrow, the higher the interest rate. Morrisville also pays its bills off the backs of homeowners rather than businesses. Even the accounting community recognises this as a bad thing and raises the interest rate accordingly. Takeaway from this: Morrisville is a less than excellent credit risk. Keep thinking car dealers for a moment: Where does your credit rating allow you to buy cars and what is your interest rate?

William Hellmann CPA also maintains, quite correctly, that interest rates are going to fall. The Federal Reserve just made an emergency interest rate cut to boost the economy, and I doubt that it was the last one for the short term. Returning the money now means 1) we can retire the high interest money now, but 2) we need better current interest rates to defease the debt because the lower the rates drop, the more money we need to put up to accomplish the defeasement. We can then 3) borrow less money (say, $10 million rather than $30 million) to continue renovating the school at a lower interest rate because the principal borrowed is smaller and we're using today's rates rather than the rates of two years ago.

Once the bond is defeased, it "goes away" and in theory, the tax millage increase that borrowing this money represented also goes away.

So far, this seems fairly straightforward, and perhaps the reasoning of the rules-bound Mr William Hellmann CPA is valid up to this point. A bond defeasement does seem to be the more prudent choice at this time if these criteria were the only issue. However, this is only the first part of a very complex situation.

There's a lot more to discuss, and I really would like to stimulate some serious discussion on this issue before the January 30 meeting. In the next post, I intended to cover the Morrisville angle of where we are, and what our current reality is. At this point, any of the defeasement options I described in the poll are possibilities. They each carry an element of risk, and I'm not sure which is "more right" than any others. I'm not sure that some of the board members will take the initiative to ask Emperor William to slow down and examine the issue more closely. But there's the challenge. It's out on the table for any of the eight remaining board members to pick up.

Friday, January 25, 2008

Free Form Friday


Plenty to read today in the BCCT. Angry Al, Kate Fratti's column, and the Gateway project are all hot topics. There's also the body slam applied by the BCCT to Hellmann's Heroes. It's too good to pass up posting it below.

Also thanks to the anonymous graphic artist. :)

Do you have anything to add?

No more secrecy

More than a hundred people jammed Wednesday's Morrisville school board meeting. Probably half of them wanted to be heard. After all, the board was meeting just days after it leaked out that members were secretly considering shutting down the borough's 116-year-old high school program, and that Morrisville kids were being shopped around to other school districts.


Hey, if you take 'em, we'll pay you!


No wonder people stormed the meeting. But rather than patiently listening to folks who wanted to be heard — every one of them, as the board should have — board President William Hellmann invoked a rule to limit public participation. He allowed only 15 citizens to sign up to speak. And he gave them just three minutes each to be heard — 45 minutes total.


And he wouldn't budge.


Nice way for a community leader to treat the people he's supposed to be serving. But folks didn't just lose an opportunity to vent, an opportunity they deserved. The board squandered the possibility that citizens might have had some practical suggestions.


Maybe board members don't realize it, but they don't know everything.


Indeed, this arrogant bunch has little consideration for anybody who disagrees with them. By law, the school closure/student exportation discussion should have been held publicly. Instead, it occurred behind closed doors. And if Hellman gets his way, the general public will continue to be shut out.


Hellman promised at Wednesday's meeting that no decision will be made without a referendum. We're glad to hear that. We weren't happy to hear there will be more closed doors — and neither should residents. We refer to a meeting the board president intends to organize between board members and a select group of citizens, students and teachers. The plan is to brainstorm ideas and discuss options.


Better late than never.


Problem is, he intends to make it a so-called executive session, meaning the general public would be barred.


That's illegal. And Morrisville citizens shouldn't accept it.


Hellman clearly likes to set rules. But there are also rules that he must respect and follow. To that end, we suggest he review the Pennsylvania Sunshine Act.


And then, by all means, hold a meeting. In fact, hold a few. The school board should schedule as many meetings as it takes for every citizen, students included, to be heard.


Maybe no ideas will surface that are any better than the one the board was secretly pursuing. But at least the community will have been heard at open forums where input is invited. Then and only then should the board propose shutting down an institution that is part of what makes a community whole.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Smackdown at the MV Auditorium

Great show at the MHS auditorium last night. I haven't attended a board meeting in quite a while but figured I would join the fun. I'll link to any articles later.

1: Front Page - It is our future
2: Kate Fratti - Morrisville Needs Heroes

Want to go through the mental snapshots I took?

William Hellmann CPA: My God, what an arrogant SOB! He pointedly ignores the public comment, even to the point of not responding to it. He is dismissive with the other board members. His body language is very much outward facing negative. Bonus arrogance points for cutting off public comment, but just lay off Reba Dunford, would you? It's clear you don't like her, but the way you belittle her at every possible turn is just infantile. Bully-Boy reminds me of a cocky arrogant know-it-all can't-tell-me SOB currently living in Washington DC. By the way...what's all this with "I didn't get a chance to review this" stuff. Running a one man show beginning to get a little tiring? This isn't "Hellmann's Heroes". Turn in your Type A obsessive compulsive membership card at the door.

Angry Al: Yep. The name is back. Apparently Al's been using words he shouldn't be. Tsk, tsk. At least we know now why John Jordan, former board member and head of the Bucks NAACP asked to speak last night to ask for Angry Al's resignation. Don't think this one is going away too soon. Ed Bailey may be a board member yet.

Bill Farrell: Our dark horse winner from last night. The man described as Captain Algebra (and we're still a little uncertain on why that question was asked, but...) was the one seeking to put some peace and calm on a situation that's been brewing for years. I'm not certain it's at the point of bringing Begin and Sadat to the table at Camp David, but it's a positive development.

Gloria Heater: Please stop vigorously shaking your head in agreement whenever William Hellmann CPA speaks. It appears sycophantic. Or that your bobble-head needs readjustment.

Marlys Mihok: Still on the secrecy bandwagon I see. You wanted to have an executive session at the agenda session two weeks ago and the lawyer told you no, giving you the five explicit reasons available. Now you're going after Joe Kemp for allegedly releasing information from an executive session, and it wasn't him. Rule #1: Almost nothing in an executive session remains completely executively quiet. So stop trying to negotiate in secrecy (wasn't that one of your campaign promises?) and bring it out into the open for all to see and discuss. Reflect on Bill Farrell's remarks, would you?

All Nine Members: Shame on you for limiting the public comment. The "People's Board" doesn't want to hear from the people. More supreme arrogance. Tell you what guys...go back through your propaganda from the last few years, cross out that "Sandy Gibson", insert "William Hellmann CPA" and re-read it. That's what you looked like last night.

William Hellmann CPA, part II: You get extra special "creepy" points for trying to nickel and dime the special education positions. Unfunded and/or underfunded federal and state mandates are a fact of life. Special education needs are a fact of life. It took the superintendent, quite properly, noting that the board as individuals could be civilly liable yet again (see, you've got to listen and drop the know it all act) before the approval was grudgingly given. (I believe your vote was Yes, With Reservations, followed by Bill Farrell's vote of Yes, With No Reservations. Look. Listen. Learn.) But then there's this diatribe on how the town needs to watch where the money goes. It does, but the money and the numbers have a human face. They're called students.

The students: Kudos for even showing up, and that's not meant to be condescending. Your teen years are for hanging out with your friends, doing your homework and McJob, and preparing for life, not experiencing adults playing poorly with your future. But you showed up and did a commendable job. For the most part you were quiet and respectable and direct, and that goes a long way.

Morrisville Farming Plan: It's dead, all except for the official funeral. The board members botched this one pretty well. "Brainstorming" is collecting ideas. When you start acting upon them, it's not just brainstorming anymore. Calling around to other districts was the equivalent of Commissioner Gordon shining the Batlight on a cloud for all to see. The secrecy stuff does not work.

Bond Defeasment: We don't know what we want, how we're getting it, or how much it will cost, but we're getting rid of the bond. William Hellmann's buddy apparently needs the work after the rocky economic news so far for 2008. What's he getting anyway? Even a 1% management fee is some $24,000. The Six Million Dollar Shell sits there, patiently crumbling, er, waiting for someone, anyone to fix it. Even the board members are confused by this maneuver. Call them, write them, and be sure to attend the special meeting on January 30 to discuss it. Remember that the devil is in the details: Where are the engineer reports, the specs, the bids, the cost analysis, the due diligence?

M.R. Reiter and Grandview RIP: The shouts of "what about the other schools" were met with silence last night and here's why. Both those schools are in poor physical shape, especially Reiter. The stop the schoolers campaigned against a K-12 building because they didn't want those age ranges mixing. So, close the two elementary schools, make MHS a K-8 building, farm out grades 9-12 and we're done! Except that it's now looking like the Six Million Dollar Shell will be a K-12 building. One order of Karma Crow for the Stop the Schoolers, extra spicy!

Enough from this side of the monitor. Anyone else have anything to share?

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Borough Budget Blowout!

Oops. It looks like even the borough tax increase is going to be bigger than expected. Expected revenues are not meeting those expectations. Now that William Hellmann CPA has moved his expertise to the school board, the borough is failing. Or does this mean that this is what we can expect from the school board budget once Billy Boy is done?

Council reopens budget talks to discuss shortfall

By DANNY ADLER
Bucks County Courier Times

Because of unexpected expenses that have arisen following approval of the 2008 budget, the council decided to reopen its spending plan Tuesday night to account for an estimated $91,098 shortfall.

In order to account for the budget's shortcomings, municipal taxes could rise even more than the $56 increase that passed in December.

The council will hold a special budget meeting at 7 p.m. Jan. 29 at borough hall, 35 Union St. Under state law, the budget must be closed by Feb. 15.

A memo from borough Manager George Mount said the borough received $37,700 less than was budgeted from a recycling performance grant.

The borough also was left with a $20,000 expense for a workers compensation audit for 2006 and 2007, and will have to pay an additional $33,398 for 2007 and 2008, Mount said.

Those expenses were not included in the 2008 budget.

Council President Nancy Sherlock said now is the time to open the budget to avoid a bigger deficit going into next year.

According to the budget that passed in December, the owner of a property assessed at the borough average of $20,000 will pay approximately $663 in property taxes in 2008.

The $5.3 million budget was a $300,000 increase over 2007. Millage increased 2.8 mills to 33.18. The cost of 1 mill translates to about $20 for the average property owner.

Shoe on the Other Foot?

Congratulations to Ed Bailey, lately of the QSRE and now a member of the Morrisville School Board, replacing...um...replacing...um...

Wait a minute...when did he get elected? Or appointed? Who is he replacing?

In any event, Ed has provided the LOL Of The Day. We have been warned! Propaganda is effective only when the QSRE/Stop the School people are using it and it is disloyal and unAmerican when used against those same people.

By the way, my algebra skills show that $500,000 over 13 years, considering a student educated from K to 12 in Morrisville comes out to $38,461 per year. Is this the new propaganda based number we should we be using?

I'm also intrigued by Mr Bailey's insistence in infringing my civil rights to speak out.

Considering all options

In the Jan. 12 article, “Mixed reaction to outsourcing idea,” the reporter mistakenly refers to a “proposed transfer plan” for Morrisville High School students. No proposal is under consideration; rather, the school board is researching possible ways of providing quality education while controlling costs.


Our district is currently spending about $500,000 for every student that it graduates. Yet because of our small size, the high school curriculum is necessarily limited.


Perhaps outsourcing is not the solution for our struggling district, but let's get as many options on the table as possible. Every option will have its pros and cons, and whatever we choose, we will have to accept trade-offs. We are already accepting trade-offs even if we are not aware of them; we need to assess our options to find out what opportunities we are missing.


Those of you who supported the K-12 school need to end your propaganda war against the school board if you want your wishes to be considered. If you can only deliver 350 votes, and nothing the school board does can please you, why should they bother?


Ed Bailey

Morrisville school board

Showdown at the MV Corral

Tonight is the night to give the school board a big fat red "F" in their performance. The meeting has been moved to the MHS auditorium, 7:30 P.M. If you want to speak, I understand that they are maneuvering, quite legally, using standing board policies and general annoyance tactics, to limit public speaking as much as possible. I suggested this last night and will suggest it again: Have two clean printed copies of your remarks available. If you don't get to talk because they cut you off, give one copy to the board secretary and the second to the BCCT reporter that will be there.

However, it's not just about the farm program. That's not even on the agenda, but please bring out your tar and pitchforks and let them know how you feel about that issue.

Tonight the bond defeasement will be taken up. After yesterday's emergency interest rate cut, William Hellmann CPA's money buddy will have to re-do the figures. This is the first step in the bankrupting of the school district.

Basically, the money goes in a long term account and earns interest to pay off the bondholders. We're holding on to some of that to pay for the Six Million Dollar Shell renovations.

This is a one shot deal. Once the money is gone, it's gone. Six million is not enough to do the job, no matter if the high school students stay or go. They have no studies showing this cost. They have no quotes even hinting at this cost. All they have is the word of their construction buddies. When was the last time you took your contractor, mechanic, or any other service provider at their word?

If you just watch the magicians as they make the money go and the taxes continue to rise without letting them know it's risky, then when your tax bill arrives, holler and scream at yourself. You're the one that let the school board do it to you.

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Job Performance Poll Closed

Thanks to everyone who voted only once. The new poll software seems to keep the Cook County Democrats out of the polling booth.

Here's the results. I don't have much to say. None of this is a surprise and with nothing to compare the figures to, it seems prudent to let this sit for another month or three and compare.


Monday, January 21, 2008

Board Meeting Times and Public Comment

I received this information from a reliable source.

The BCCT this weekend, in their two articles about this week's meeting, indicated an incorrect start time. In Manasee's article she said it starts at 7:00. In the listing of "Meetings this week" for the entire county, the paper says it starts at 8:00pm. In reality it starts at 7:30pm. I have already notified the paper of this error. Hopefully they will correct it.

Secondly, apparently you can only sign-up for public comment up until 7:30pm. At 7:31 you will be too late and not permitted to speak. So those interested in speaking should be prompt or early. Secondly, the sign-in sheet has recently been placed in front of the Board president, not off to the side as was previous Board practice. Those who have spoken in the past may need this new bit of direction.

Sunday, January 20, 2008

Apologies for the Delay in Posting...

...but when I was reading the paper this morning I spit coffee all over the paper itself. Then, I think I sprained my keyboard accessing the BCCT website to re-read this letter.

School closing no big deal; you'll get over it, kids

As a veteran of the Neshaminy/Maple Point debacle of 1975, I too was upset at the thought of losing friends to a “foreign” school. Guess what? I survived and my quality of life shows no ill effects from my experience. And I have news for the kids of Morrisville. The things that they think are life and death issues now, in five years, will not matter at all.


They must realize that as public school students, they are required to attend the school that the public (the taxpayers) can afford to provide. This is Morrisville, not Beverly Hills. When these kids become taxpayers, they will understand.


As for the kids who say they will drop out of school if they are sent elsewhere, I hope they realize that even if they do drop out, their parents will still be required to pay school taxes. Again, in time none of this will matter — except whether or not they have a diploma. These kids shouldn't throw away the opportunity to become a useful, productive citizen just because they think they are being treated unfairly. This is not a personal issue.


Isn't it also unfair for long-time Morrisville residents (especially senior citizens and those on fixed incomes) to lose their homes or be forced to move because they can no longer afford to live here? Be assured that the fallout from this issue will affect them long after these kids have gone on to their post-high school lives. These kids need to realize that, in the big picture, what they want, or don't want, does not take precedence over the needs (or very survival) of a whole community.


Whatever happens, kids, believe me, you'll get over it. So get out of bed, get dressed and go to school — wherever that is.


Wow. And people like this get to vote, drive, and everything.

Dear Letter Writer: How many borough council and/or school board meetings have you attended in the past few years? Are you part of the solution, or just heckling from the sidelines?

Let's start with the main topic, where you are somewhat correct despite channelling Captain Obvious: school is school, and you can learn wherever the school is. You will make new friends wherever you go. It is not the end of the world, and every one of us who has survived puberty and our teen years does know that.

Having said that, what are you smoking? You go off on dropouts and how parents need to make sure their kids attend schools. The same is true of the people of the town. They are as equally obligated to provide the place for the schooling to occur.

Beverly Hills? Please. At least compare apples to oranges. You insult all of us when you compare Morrisville like that. Morrisville is a good place to live. It's a good place to bring up children. And, it's a good place to grow old in. I'll live here any day over Beverly Hills. Why do you see it differently?

You're right: This is not a personal issue and I wish the seniors of this borough would take a deep breath for just a moment and reflect on what they are doing. I will ask it again, this time not in a comment, but in a post. Where were you in the 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, 1990s and 2000s when the pottery closed, the rubber mill burned and the steel mill died? What did you do then to make things better for today? Did you attend council meetings, school board meetings, and business association meetings to make a difference? I'll give your criticisms more credence if you did. I'm working today for the Morrisville of the 2010s, 2020s, 2030s, and beyond. What are you working for?

I am not indifferent to the tax burdens placed on all of us. I pay high taxes too, but which of you is approaching our borough council to get the Gateway project started? Let's get some tax revenue into this place so the residential taxes can go down for a change. All we hear from are the same old people who want the Morrisville of their youth to reappear. News flash: It ain't happening. You want lower school taxes? Raise the tax revenue by supporting new buildings and the revitalization of downtown. When those front line people supporting a newer and better Morrisville are out there working, do they see you working side by side with them?

I'm not collecting it yet, but where's MY Social Security? There are too many burdens placed on that system for it to continue too much longer, but by law, I'm required to pay for that too. At least you get to complain about the school taxes. I have no choice but to see more of my paycheck go toward supporting the seniors. Since the seniors are calling for a general strike on the youth of this borough, what if the tables were turned and we, the wage earners, stop paying into Social Security?

Let's turn your own words around: You must realize that as taxpayers, you need to live in the house you can afford. I'm very sorry that inflation and recession and all manner of economic ills have befallen all of us. But why do you want to be protected, yet think it odd for the children to be protected too? Let's continue..."you need to realize that in the big picture, what you want, or don't want, does not take precedence over the needs (or very survival) of a whole community." You're looking very small picture at the seniors. Let's expand your vision just a bit, shall we? Look in the mirror and read that paragraph again.

Are you really sure this is the way you want to go? Generational wars where one side loses out in favor of another? I've seen this play out in a number of cities and towns. When one side has to lose out, eventually the entire town suffers. This isn't just about you.

The board meeting is this Wednesday, January 23, 2008 at 7:30 P.M. I will expect our letter writer to be there and to sign up to speak. Otherwise, your words today are meaningless. Whatever happens, you'll get over it, won't you?

The soapbox is now available. Next speaker?

Friday, January 18, 2008

Did You Get a Postcard?

I got a postcard. It came in the mail yesterday. Anyone have any thoughts or perspective they want to share?

Important Morrisville Community News

Do you know what the new Morrisville School Board is up to...

Farming out all of the High School students to other districts, even Catholic schools.

Cutting sports, after school programs, teacher training, and textbooks.

Using their friends to advise them on facility and financial matters.

Selling the A-Field meaning and creating a hardship for the Little Bulldogs and Holy Trinity

Trying to bankrupt the Morrisville School District with no renovations

Please come to the next School Board meeting, Wednesday January 23rd at 7:30 P.M at the Middle Senior High School (LGI Room) lo learn more.

Find out what else they're up to!

Opinion Polls

I thought I would try something, and if it works out, it could be a regular monthly thing.

As of today, what is your opinion of the school board? No trick questions or hidden meanings. As a PSP or NSN, do you approve or disapprove of the job the current school board is doing? Polls close January 21 and are located to the left of this question in the sidebar.

Don't forget to vote in the Morrisville Farm Association poll as well.

Thursday, January 17, 2008

The People Are Ticked!

Today I thought I would share the contents of the mailbag with everyone. Many people blind copied me on letters that were sent to the board members, the superintendent, and the Courier Times. A few did grant permission to publish excepts here and I appreciate their openness.

It appears that the people of Morrisville are generally cranky about this rather bizarre and underhanded desperation move by the Stop the School board members. Stop the School didn't mean Close the School.

Just a reminder: the next meeting is in the MHS LGI room on January 23, 2008 at 7:30 P.M. However, my Crystal Ball tells me a larger venue will be needed.

On to the mailbag...

Letter 1: I am firmly and vigorously against your plan to "Farm Out" our students to Conwell-Egan or to any religious based school. Any tax payer dollars going to a religious based institution is a violation of the US Constitution.

I am a Roman Catholic, a taxpayer, and a parent; but I am an American first, and I believe that this scheme is nothing but an attempt to starve the Morrisville School District out of existence.

Letter 2: Oh and this point: We are the candidates that pledge to work together with the parents and residents, in an open and honest partnership in the best interest of our children’s education. Where was the working together with parents and residents when deciding to farm out the children? Perhaps PLEDGE means something different to me….again I must check the dictionary. While I am at it, I will look up OPEN and HONEST as well.

With your help we pledge:

to provide a quality education for our children. By making the students share books?
a curriculum that will enable our children to achieve proficiency on the PSSA tests and academic excellence.
state of the art technology for grades K through 12. Will we be busing the state of the art technology with the 9th-12th graders? We made need a bigger bus!
a financial management plan to assure every possible dollar goes into educational programs and materials and stops waste. Again, by sharing books?

Letter 3: I have not bought a home in Morrisville to take advantage of the small school system only to see my children bused ridiculous distances to a school where they will be outcasts.

I admit that removing high school students from the mix is certainly a novel way to raise the test scores in 11th grade.

Brainstorming is a wonderful tool. It exposes the stupid ideas rather quickly. Publicly, quickly, now, expose this stupid idea and abandon it.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

On The Road to Closing

The BCCT addresses the idea of closing today.

District must navigate code for closing

By JO CIAVAGLIA
Bucks County Courier Times

Unless Morrisville School District submits a plan, the state Department of Education can't definitively say if the district can close its only high school and send its students elsewhere.

Pennsylvania school code is so complicated it's impossible to speculate if the district meets state school closure criteria, what would happen to its students or if neighboring district high schools could be forced to accept them, education department spokesman Michael Race said.

Last week it was revealed that some members of the new Morrisville school board majority have contacted local school systems to see if they'd be interested in accepting its high school students on a tuition basis. For years, the 1,000-student district has been plagued with financial and academic problems.

Charles Herring, an attorney for the state education association and Morrisville teachers union, said this week the union would oppose any attempt to tuition out students.

He added that state precedent exists, which he believes prevents a school board from closing a school and furloughing employees covered under existing union contracts.

Before any district can proceed with a school closing, a plan must be submitted and state-required steps followed, including holding a public hearing to discuss the possible closure at least three months before action is taken. It's unclear what additional requirements apply to school closings that would involve educating students out of a district.

In Pennsylvania, over the last 23 years, at least three school districts — Midland and Duquesne outside Pittsburgh and St. Clair Area in Schuylkill County — have closed high schools and transferred students into neighboring district schools. Each district's set of circumstances and tuition arrangements is so unique to that district that none can be used as a comparison with Morrisville, Race said.

“The particulars of any school closure vary, so it's impossible to speculate on the particulars of Morrisville unless or until the district would outline a closure plan,” Race said. “There are so many areas of the code that could affect this it is difficult to get into a what-if situation.”

Parts of the state school code suggest if a district doesn't have a school, its students would attend the nearest and most convenient school district, Race said. The code does not address what would happen if a district has no room in its school or a policy limiting or barring tuition students.

Take the Midland Borough School District, which closed its high school in 1985. Initially it transferred students to a nearby district's high school, but when the district abruptly ended the agreement — and other districts refused to accept the students — Midland was forced to send the students across state lines.

The district is now the only one in Pennsylvania that sends its students to a high school in East Liverpool, Ohio.

Pennsbury School District, which borders Morrisville, has a board policy that narrowly defines which tuition students can attend the district, district CEO Paul Long said. But that policy doesn't address the potential situation in Morrisville.

“If we got to the point of facing that question with Morrisville, it would be aside from that policy,” Long said.

Neither Bristol Township nor Neshaminy, nearby school districts with underused schools, has a written board policy defining tuition students it will accept into the district.

The state school code also dictates a specific process for closing a school, and there is a general criteria that must be met — such as dwindling student population, poor building condition or shrinking tax base — but each school closure has individual circumstances that must be considered, Race said.

St. Clair Area School District closed its high school in 1990 after experiencing teacher contract problems and falling student enrollment, a district official said. The students now attend nearby Pottsville High School, though the closing resulted in years of legal battles with its teachers union.

A state-appointed board decided to close Duquesne City School District's high school in June, seven years after the 775-student district was named to a state list of 12 financially and academically distressed districts.

Specific state legislation was added to the school code to dictate some of the particulars of the Duquesne closure, including giving state Education Secretary Gerald Zahorchak the authority to reassign nearly 200 high school students to nearby school districts, over those districts' objections.

Starting this school year, Duquesne high school students attend West Mifflin Area or East Allegheny School Districts. The district continues to educate its K-8 students. West Mifflin Area and East Allegheny have filed a joint lawsuit seeking to overturn Zahorchak's decision.

The state code also doesn't spell out what the per-student tuition rate for sending school districts would be, Race said.

Applying the charter school funding principle, the money follows the student, meaning whatever the sending district receives in state funding is what the charter school receives. But per-student costs vary by district and it's unclear if a sending or accepting district's rate applies — and which district would make up any cost difference.

The school code dictates that terms of “tuition out” students can be determined by the districts, so the cost of reimbursement for the students could be negotiated between the sending and accepting districts, Race said.

Montgomery County's Bryn Athyn School District, the state's lone paper-only district, sends all its public school students to neighboring Lower Moreland School District.

The district operates no public school buildings. Most children attend the Academy of the New Church, a private school operated by the Swedenborgian church, whose world headquarters is Bryn Athyn.

This year there are eight Bryn Athyn students attending Lower Moreland schools, Lower Moreland business manager Mark McGuinn said.

Bryn Athyn pays the state-certified Lower Moreland tuition rate of $9,297 for elementary students and $10,833 for secondary students. There is a separate hourly rate for services for special education students, he added.

Lower Moreland also has a board policy specifying the only tuition students it accepts are from Bryn Athyn.

Did you know...

As of the 2006-07 school year, Pennsylvania had 65 school districts with 1,000 or fewer students.

Of the 501 school districts in the state, 39 percent have fewer than 3,000 students.

Staff writers Rachel Canelli and Joan Hellyer contributed to this story.
Jo Ciavaglia can be reached at 215 949-4181 or jciavaglia@phillyBurbs.com.

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

A Bridge to a New School Redux

Do you remember the collapse of the bridge in Minnesota? I blogged about it way back on August 3, and it directly addressed the issues of age, lack of adequate maintenance, and lack of follow-up.

Apparently, the final reports are being assembled and written. A "design flaw" is the apparent conclusion of the report.

The official, who was briefed by the National Transportation Safety Board, said that investigators found a design flaw in the bridge's gusset plates, which are the steel plates that tie steel beams together.

Meanwhile, Transportation Secretary Mary Peters is expected to issue an advisory later Tuesday urging states to check the gusset plates when modifications are made to a bridge -- such as changes to the weight of the bridge or adding a guardrail, said a federal official with knowledge of the plans.

Currently, such calculations are done for the entire bridge, but not down to the gusset plates, the official said.
[Ed Note: What is waiting inside the Six Million Dollar Shell? This board's need for speed is a recipe for further disaster.]

Last August, Peters advised states to consider the additional stress placed on bridges during construction projects. An 18-person crew was working on the bridge when it collapsed.

Nearly three months later, Peters told a gathering in Washington of a "working theory" of a poorly designed gusset plate and a heavy load of construction materials.

The bridge was deemed "structurally deficient" by the federal government as far back as 1990.


Do you see any other parallels here?

Comic Relief

I found these two Dilbert cartoons recently talking about budgeting and design in the real world that seemed to refer back to budgeting and the radical shifts being made from the world of the possible into the Twilight Zone of Unreality that has become a hallmark of the new Morrisville School Board.

Then...Santa Claus made an unannounced late visit. I thank the gifted graphic artist who provided us with the seal of approval for Morrisville's school budgets!




I'll have to add "Leadership by Words" to my business lexicon along with "developing synergies" and "involuntarily downsized." Oops, sorry to all the high school teachers, I should have never said that.



And once we apply this regal seal, ask the question...are we REALLY bringing out the best, or preparing for bringing out the dead?

Note: In the office pool, I have the 4-6PM slot today for a witty commentary from jon. While I do appreciate everyone's comments, jons are pretty much along my same style of humor and I look forward to them!

Monday, January 14, 2008

NEWS TIP: Students to NJ?

I have some information from an very credible source which is not yet confirmed. The general sense is:

[Hold on to your hat. I just got a call from a headmaster of a private Catholic academy in New Jersey who wants his school to be part of the mix when it comes time to "farm out."]

Can anyone second this information?

Sunday, January 13, 2008

Telephone Numbers

I was going through some old documentation here and I was struck by a telephone number. You know, something like 867-5309 or Pennsylvania 65000.

I was looking through an old Stop the School brochure and I noticed the telephone number 215-295-2900 listed as a place where the Stop the School people would tirelessly answer the phone and get you a voter registration form. I even blogged this back a month ago and never did this search. So I Googled the number. Imagine what I found.



Did the Historic Morrisville Society make an illegal campaign contribution to the Stop the School candidates by providing this service?

The Children Are Playing With The Poll Again

I'm watching you do it right now. 8:10 AM Sunday morning.

1:30 PM Sunday afternoon
I reposted the poll, so if you already voted, please vote again. I actually like the idea that a ballot box stuffer thinks that over voting will make me sit here and cry and pack up my blog and go home. Well, OK, I am already home, but my self-esteem just doubled because I'm so important to you that you need to consume your day with reloading your browser and reclicking on the mouse.

I bet I can keep this up longer than you can!

The Sunday Funny Papers

Here it is, Sunday morning and the kids have the funny pages open from the Sunday paper. Oddly enough, the parents have the funny pages open too, but while the kids are looking at the comics, the parents are anxiously reading about our little town's Farm Control Board, looking for the new scheduling of the cattle runs to Bristol and Pennsbury, and maybe even a few to Conwell Egan.

Were you able to contact your board members? Several of you did and were kind enough to include me on the letters, and I thank you for that. Most of you asked that your letters not be reprinted here and I am honoring that request. However, I thought that I was hot under the collar. Perhaps we should talk to George Mount about adding blood pressure medication directly to the town water supply to save time.

According to the BCCT this morning, closing a school is a slow process, and it takes at least three months.

All this board wants is fast, fast, relief. WARNING: Everything is moving fast. Defease the debt FAST! Cut the budget FAST! I know some people so we can fix the school FAST! These are the same people who wanted s...l...o...w... action from the past board, aren't they? Then what is the "other reason" for going fast? This new board has two years at least to complete the job. Who else benefits from fast action?

They also attacked the past president for her "connections" with contractors. Who is questioning the connections that William Hellmann CPA has with the professional defeasement artist who also said come back and see me when you need more money. Other members are using connections to bring their friends directly into the process because they can "work with these people", not like the others before them who were greedy and only wanted a new school. "Work with you", huh? Sounds like a classic sweetheart pay-for-play or inexpensive-work-now-for-guaranteed-work-later type of scam is being run. Even the door locks at Grandview had to be fixed by a William Hellmann CPA crony ("Did you call the guy I told you to call?" was his message to the business administrator).

What's the school board equivalent of a special prosecutor?

And are we following the Sandy Gibson Rule? Substitute Sandy as the protagonist and then read how it sounds. For example, in the above paragraph...Who is questioning the connections that [Sandy Gibson] has with the professional defeasement artist who also said come back and see me when you need more money. [Sandy Gibson is] using connections to bring [her] friends directly into the process because they can "work with these people", not like the others before them who were greedy and only wanted a new school. "Work with you", huh? Sounds like a classic sweetheart pay-for-play or inexpensive-work-now-for-guaranteed-work-later type of scam is being run. Even the door locks at Grandview had to be fixed by a [Sandy Gibson] crony ("Did you call the guy I told you to call?" was [her] message to the business administrator).

See how easy that was? If you were incensed by reading that last paragraph and went outside to stoke the vat of boiling tar to corner Sandy, why aren't you doing it to William Hellmann CPA? Because you're a hypocrite, that's why.

One item to close with:

Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.
Margaret Mead, US anthropologist (1901 - 1978)